Skip to main content

Table 1 Advantages and challenges of silicon nanoparticle fabrication method

From: Silicon nanoparticles: fabrication, characterization, application and perspectives

Method

 

Advantages

Challenges

Top-down

Etching and grinding

Relativiely simple fabrication process

Reduced sphericity of the resulting silicon nanoparticles

Laser ablation

Spherical silicon nanoparticles

Broad size distribution

Laser printing

Spherical silicon nanoparticles positioned at desired location

Production volume limitation

Bottom-up

Pyrolysis of silane

Mass production

Difficulty in controlling the nanoparticle size

Reduction of silicon tetrachlorid

Mass production with low cost

Difficulty in controlling the nanoparticle size and generation of by-products

Reduction of silica particles

Carbothermal reduction

Reduction of relatively inexpensive silica for silicon nanoparticle production

Reaction at temperatures above 2000 °C

Magnesiothermic reduction

Reduction of relatively inexpensive silica for silicon nanoparticle production at temperatures around 650 °C

Incomplete reduction resulting in the formation of unreacted silica or magnesium silicide